Get Quotes Contact Us Sign In
Website
Call
Jonny C's NY Deli & Caterers Buffalo might be the City of Good Neighbors but Western New York is an all-around great place to live. After all, it's not just the people we love, but the food too! A deli is the perfect place to grab a bite to eat because all of our meats, subs, sandwiches, wraps, and more are prepared fresh and cooked to order. We understand how hectic your schedule can be and strive to always provide fast, reliable service. At Jonny C's we are proud to provide not just a self-service deli for dining on-the-go but Buffalo catering services to the entire Western New York community.
Follow us
Services
Darcy has lived in WNY his entire life. He recently moved to Lockport with his wife, Nicole, and their two young children. Darcy's passion for food service began at Brookfield Country Club at the young age of 16. In 2008, after gaining much of his experience at the country club, Darcy decided to move on to work at Jonny C's.
In addition to our catering services, we also have a self-service deli featuring an open dining room-a perfect lunch spot! Get delicious overstuffed subs and sandwiches, salads, burgers, wraps, and more. All of our prices are affordable, but our service and food is out of this world and can't be beat!
Jonny C's NY Deli is a New York style deli located in East Amherst, New York. We offer various different cold cuts, specialty sandwiches, sides, soups & salads, and finger food. In addition to our Buffalo catering services, we also have a New York style deli! There is nothing better than a fresh sub filled with the best meats. All of our prices are affordable, but our service and food is out of this world and can't be beat!
While we would love nothing more than to fulfill every request, the simple truth is that we experience such a high volume of donation requests each year that it is not possible to provide for everyone that makes a submission. Our company policy is to provide donations to people, charities, and organizations that have supported us by being patrons. Please be sure to include a copy of your flyer or receipt so we have details regarding your donation.
Reviews (19)
Write a Review
Guy Zaczek
Jun 21, 2022
The place is very crowded for lunch because everyone knows how good they are.
Arunabh Chaudhuri
Jun 17, 2022
They have a wide selections of subs and sandwiches! Great quality food
Lolly Stevenson
Apr 27, 2022
Out shopping and got a little hungry, decided to go in and it was So worth it. GREAT chicken sub ans fries. I will Definitely come back. Lolly N BFLO
Christine K.
Feb 28, 2022
The menu might seem a bit daunting but everything is good. My family loves the matzo ball soup, Reuben's and clubs.
Paula G.
Feb 08, 2022
Reuben sandwich was very good. Nice that you can order 1/2 or full sandwich
Marla B.
Feb 08, 2022
I have been a customer of Jonny C's for YEARS! I have eaten in, taken out and had a variety of events catered by Darcy and his Crew. There aren't enough stars to give them. Their food is fresh, creative, and delicious. ONLY to be outdone by their service and friendly demeanor. Last night, I picked up a pretty large order for my family (we are a family of six).

One has a dairy issue, another wants sauces on the side, another wants the bread toasted a certain way. I ordered online which can sometimes be questionable at other restaurants. Not only was my order ready on time, but the young man behind the counter took painstaking efforts to double and triple check that everything was there and that everything was done to my specifications. OUTSTANDING.
Shawn H.
Dec 24, 2021
My father and I stopped in for lunch.the food pretty good but way over priced. 2 Reubens 2 drinks & 2 french onion soups ran me $40.00. Maybe come up with a soup and sandwich combo with a better price and I'd rate 5 stars.
Anthony Bateau
Sep 07, 2021
These guys are awesome! They've catered 2 of our events. You can eat in for subs and other deli stuff. We have been very satisfied, each time we have used them. The staff is great!
Sam B.
Sep 06, 2021
Our go to Deli restaurant for veggie burgers and our favorite. the portobello burger with roasted red peppers, pesto Mayo, blue cheese crumbles, onion, tomato and lettuce! Their fries are crispy, thick and yummy. They do need to upgrade their veggie burgers to the impossible burger! Service is always good for both Eat-in or takeout and a great casual place to have a quick lunch or for those days when you are too tired to cook dinner! Highly recommend!
Maureen W.
Sep 02, 2021
Really enjoyed the mild chicken finger sub and cheeseburger sub I had from here recently! The subs had lots of toppings and the veggies on (tomato, lettuce, onion) tasted fresh and crisp. Their French fries were really really good too - so crispy and not soggy.
J. Hunt
Aug 28, 2021
If your into deli sandwiches and wraps, you must come here. I had the chicken finger wrap, that consisted of coleslaw, cheese and a sweet tangy habanero sauce. I am not into spicy foods, but even I enjoyed the tangy heat that this wrap had. I suggest you get extra napkins, because this wrap is juicy. Johnny C's has so many options, that you can choose from. I would be very difficult, not to be able to find something you like.
Ashley E.
Aug 10, 2021
This place is quickly becoming a favorite for everyone in the household. We had Johnny C's last night again. This time I got the ranch rover sub. It was a little spicy, messy and so good. As usual, I ordered online. We also had The Memphis, Soul Stealer( another favorite of mine!), and The Transporter. If you can't find something on this menu then you have a problem. This place is so so so good!
Dee I.
Jun 03, 2021
A little over priced for the quantity but the quality was as expected. Staff was not attentive and seemed a bit put off to find my online order.
Nikki C.
May 24, 2021
Jonny C's might be the best sub joint in Buffalo! The subs are huge, the bread is fresh, and the variety is amazing. I usually always get their chicken finger subs, they really load on the chicken fingers but they are flat enough so the sub doesn't fall apart after each bite. I usually go hot on the sauce, which the breading on the tender soaks up so its not messy and doesn't make the roll soggy.

The Pittsburgh sub has tender chopped steak with a sweet kick of coleslaw and fresh veggies - it's usually my "dessert" sub after a hot chicken finger one! I grew up around the corner from Jonny C's, so we'd get it all the time. but now even though I live a little more than 15 min away, we'll still make the longer drive for their great takeout service.
Sp Galvin
Apr 21, 2021
So many great sandwiches! I pick a different one everytime I go!
Katie G.
Nov 04, 2020
Love the turkey natural sub! A bit too much turkey on it for me, but it's so good. Get it!
Lee B.
Oct 10, 2020
Ordered the eggplant parmigiana sub. It was really good. Eggplant slices were a good thickness and not over cooked. Lots of cheese and a good amount of sauce, but not so much that you can't pick up the sandwich. I've also had the seafood bisque. It has good flavor, but is a little salty. It also has imitation crab. Orders have always been ready on time.
Melissa M.
Jan 19, 2020
Jonny C's is our local go-to spot for subs. In my opinion, they are the best in the area. The rolls, meats, and other ingredients are all incredibly fresh. On my most recent visit, I opted for a salad and the chicken Caesar did not disappoint. I will be adding it to the rotation.
Aaron C.
Dec 25, 2019
This place is a sub gem! Currently 60 different subs on the menu and all of them are topped to the max. So far I've tried a couple different ones and haven't been disappointed once and am starting to think there isn't a bad option on the menu! Very reasonable pricing, food is ready quickly and great rolls to top off a loaded meal with all sorts of options.

No doubt this is a place that you should stop at if you're in the area but be ready to leave either with a full stomach or with some leftovers. They also offer a few eating challenges to those that are feeling bold enough to test their courage. Highly suggest!